Summary

The 2024/573 EU F-gas regulations impose strict conditions on future use of SF6 and F-gases or their mixtures with GWP higher than 1000. Therefore, many electricity utilities are adopting strategies to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, which include restricting the usage of SF6 gas and replacing it with gases that not only possess the required insulating performance but also have a reduced GWP. For new transmission network equipment and installations, the focus is mainly on fluoronitrile based gas mixtures and atmospheric gases. However, this transition can introduce complexity in condition monitoring and defect diagnostic systems.

This paper specifically focuses on ultra-high frequency-based PD measurement analysis for three candidate alternative gases. A series of custom-designed test cells were fabricated to replicate idealized defect topologies commonly found in GIS. Partial discharge inception voltage measurements were performed using all test gases for different pressures to compare their performance. The characteristic features of phase-resolved partial discharge data are compared for the different defects in both C4-FN gas mixtures and atmospheric gases. By referencing historically established PD characteristics in SF6, we evaluate the applicability of existing diagnostic criteria to the new gas mixtures and identify case-specific deviations. Fast

Fourier Transform (FFT) spectral analysis reveals defect-dependent characteristics, with distinct frequency peaks observed across different defect types. These observations are further supported by variations in the energy distribution specific to each PD defect.

These findings link key PD metrics with eco-friendly gases to identify defect signatures.

Frequency response analysis enables the distinction of different PD defects, as each type of defect produces a distinctive FFT spectrum and energy distribution. The findings are particularly relevant to industry, especially for network operators requiring condition monitoring of assets insulated with alternative gases using UHF PD sensors.

Additional informations

Publication type Session Materials
Reference D1_11306_2026
Publication year
Publisher CIGRE
Country United Kingdom
Study committees
File size 1 MB
Price for non member 30 €
Price for member 30 €

Authors

ULLAH Rahmat - Cardiff University UK; REID Alistair - Cardiff University UK; HADDAD Manu - Cardiff University UK; TADDEI Peter - SSEN Transmission UK; NAMBIAR Mini - SSEN Transmission UK; BARNETT Matthew - SSEN Transmission UK

Keywords

UHF, Alternative gas, Condition monitoring, GIS, Partial discharge.

UHF-Based Partial Discharge Diagnostics in SF6-Alternative Gases